高平堂World Fan Clan Digital GenealogyGaoping Hall · Ancestral Hall in the Cloud

Series I · Three Thousand Years and the Southeast Asian Founders (Vols. 1–12) · Vol. 4

The Life of Fan Zhongyan, Duke Wenzheng

From fatherless boy to reforming minister of the Qingli era (989–1052)

Northern Song · reigns of Zhenzong and Renzong · About 6 min read

Text size

1. The orphan Zhu Yue

晝夜不息,冬月憊甚,以水沃面;食不給,至以糜粥繼之,人不能堪,仲淹不苦也。

He studied day and night; in winter when worn out he poured water on his face; when food ran short he lived on gruel. Others could not bear it; Zhongyan did not find it hard.

History of Song, Biography of Fan Zhongyan

Fan Zhongyan, courtesy name Xiwen, of Wu county in Suzhou, was born in 989. His father Fan Yong died when he was two; his mother, Lady Xie, remarried into the Zhu family of Changshan, and the boy took his stepfather's name as Zhu Yue. When he grew up and learned of his origins, he tearfully took leave of his mother and went to study in the Southern Capital, Yingtian, at the school founded by Qi Tongwen.

His biography in the History of Song says he studied day and night without rest; on winter nights, when exhausted, he splashed cold water on his face, and when food ran short he lived on thin gruel, a hardship others could not bear but he did not mind. Ouyang Xiu's spirit-way inscription records that in 1015 he passed the examinations, first in the Ministry of Rites round, became a judicial officer of Guangde, and brought his mother to live with him. When he was later posted to Jiqing, he resumed the surname Fan and took the name Zhongyan.

2. The sea dike: a local official's first great work

The History of Song records that early in his career Fan Zhongyan supervised the salt tax at Xixi in Taizhou. According to his chronological biography and other accounts, the sea dike there had long been neglected and tides flooded the fields; he pressed for its rebuilding, and once finished it let the coastal people live in safety. Later generations called it Lord Fan's Dike.

Later, as prefect of Suzhou, he met a great flood that left the fields unworkable. He dredged five rivers to lead Lake Tai's water to the sea and recruited workers for the project; when he was transferred to Mingzhou before it was finished, the transport commissioner asked that he stay to complete it, and the court agreed.

3. Three times he spoke out, three times he was sent away

寧鳴而死,不默而生。

Better to cry out and die than to live in silence.

Collected Works of Fan Wenzheng, Rhapsody on the Divine Crow

At court Fan Zhongyan repeatedly spoke his mind. He petitioned Empress Dowager Liu to return power to Emperor Renzong and was sent out as vice-prefect of Hezhong; when Renzong sought to depose Empress Guo, he led the remonstrators to kneel at the palace gate and was demoted to Muzhou; when he presented his Chart of the Hundred Officials criticising Chief Minister Lü Yijian's appointments, he was sent to Raozhou. When Yu Jing, Yin Zhu and Ouyang Xiu spoke up for him, all three were demoted too.

In exile he wrote the Rhapsody on the Divine Crow, using the crow that is hated for announcing misfortune to say he would rather die speaking than live in silence. The line became an emblem of the remonstrating spirit of Chinese scholars.

4. Guarding the north-west

濁酒一杯家萬里,燕然未勒歸無計。

A cup of cloudy wine, home ten thousand li away; the victory not yet carved on Yanran, there is no way back.

Fan Zhongyan, 'Pride of the Fisherman: Autumn Thoughts', Collected Works

When Yuanhao of the Western Xia rose against the Song, its armies suffered repeated defeats. In 1040 Fan Zhongyan, as an academician, became deputy pacification commissioner of Shaanxi, serving with Han Qi under Xia Song. With most of Yanzhou's forts lost, he volunteered to govern Yanzhou himself, reorganised the troops, built forts and won over the Qiang peoples, and had his eldest son Chunyou seize a key site so that Dashun fort could be built, turning a passive defence into a firmer frontier.

On the frontier he wrote the lyric 'Pride of the Fisherman: Autumn Thoughts'. Its line about a cup of cloudy wine ten thousand li from home, with no return until victory is carved on Mount Yanran, captures the soldiers' homesickness and duty; it is one of the rare frontier pieces among Song lyrics.

5. The Qingli reforms

In 1043 Fan Zhongyan became assisting chief minister. When Renzong opened the Tianzhang Pavilion and asked ministers to set out policy, he submitted his Ten Proposals in Reply to the Imperial Edict: clear promotion and dismissal, curbs on privilege, better examinations, careful choice of local heads, fair official lands, support for farming, a stronger army, lighter labour service, wider benevolence and respect for orders. At their core were reform of the bureaucracy, review of officials and change to the examinations.

The reforms touched powerful interests, and opponents attacked the reformers as a faction. In 1045 Fan Zhongyan left the council for Binzhou, and most measures lapsed. Short as it was, the Qingli reform heralded the later reforms of Wang Anshi and others.

6. Last years and legacy

仲淹內剛外和,性至孝,以母在時方貧,其後雖貴,非賓客不重肉。

Zhongyan was firm within and gentle without, and supremely filial. Because his mother had lived in poverty, even after he rose high he did not take a second meat dish except for guests.

History of Song, Biography of Fan Zhongyan

He then governed Dengzhou, Hangzhou, Qingzhou and other places. In 1046, at Dengzhou, he wrote the Record of Yueyang Tower; in 1050 he set aside estate land in Suzhou and founded the Fan Clan Estate (see volumes 5 and 6). In 1052, ill, he asked to be moved to Yingzhou, was carried as far as Xuzhou in a litter and died there, aged sixty-four by Chinese reckoning. The court named him minister of war posthumously and gave him the title Wenzheng, and Emperor Renzong wrote the heading of his memorial stele himself: Stele in Praise of the Worthy.

The History of Song describes him as firm within and gentle without, and deeply filial; because his family had been too poor to support his mother properly while she lived, even when he was rich he ate meat only when entertaining guests, and his wife and children had no more than they needed, though he gave freely to others. His four sons, Chunyou, Chunren, Chunli and Chuncui, all became well known.

Sources

  • History of Song, Biography of Fan Zhongyan · Chapter 314 · Original text
  • Collected Works of Fan Wenzheng · Divine Crow, Ten Proposals, lyrics
  • Ouyang Xiu, Spirit-Way Inscription for Fan Wenzheng · Ouyang Xiu ji, chapter 21 · Original text
  • Chronological Biography of Fan Wenzheng
  • Long Draft Continuation of the Comprehensive Mirror · first year of Kangding

This library uses only the standard histories, collected works and official records. Later attributions and folk traditions are marked in the Notes on Sources and never presented as fact.